Think about this question in the context of “Top” lists, like Letterman’s Top 10 or the types of lists I post about Halloween, etc.
This entry was posted
on Monday, November 16th, 2009 at 11:49 am and is filed under Uncategorized and tagged with poll.
You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed.
My vote of 3 is because it is encompassed by all of the other choices. If I would read 10, I would read anything less.
I had this same argument with my written test at the DMV. The question was, “How many feet can something extend out the back of your vehicle before you need a red flag? 10ft, 7ft, 5ft, 3ft” I, naturally, choose 3ft because if my personal limit was less than the legal limit, then I am still within the law. In fact, it’s even better. I got the answer wrong – it was the only question I got wrong – and I REALLY wanted to argue with the DMV worker, but I bit my tongue and accepted my drivers license with that one blemish.
Perhaps I’m not phrasing the question correctly, but in a way, I think you’ve answered: You want the shortest possible list. If you had wanted to read many many funny things, you would have chosen 10, right?
I think if I wanted to read many many funny things, I wouldn’t be satisfied with 10. 15 might tide me over. 3 is just not enough.
In my opinion, 3 things barely qualifies as a list. It seems more like the beginning of a list. It leaves me with an “OK, I’m primed and getting into this…now where are the rest?”…Like a wedding that only serves appetizers and leaves you angry that you went to the the trouble of putting on a suit and tie just for some wilted piece of asparagus with some unrecognizable cheesy cajun sauce on it. A list of 3 is no more than an appetizer. 5 is a borderline appetizer/minimum in my book.
So what is a topic for which 3 items is the optimal number of items? Surely there’s something out there. It seems so far that people want Top 10 lists of funny things and Top 5 lists of advice. I think 3 works for lists of things that you want to be able to remember really easily. Like my entry about conversation fodder. If I had made that list 10 different things, they’d be tough to remember. But 3 is easy.
[…] to Read? 2009 November 25 tags: poll by jameystegmaier Okay, this is the last survey in this chain. I’m curious about the optimal list length for favorites and recommendations. Like, favorite […]
Mail (will not be published) (required)
Notify me of followup comments via e-mail
Enter your email address to send future blog posts to your inbox.
Join 16,259 other subscribers
Powered by WordPress
Design by Graph Paper Press
Subscribe to entries
Subscribe to comments
All content © 2020 by jameystegmaier.com