Was the Best Battlefield Scene Ever on Game of Thrones This Week?

Game-of-Thrones-liveblog--Battle-of-the-Bastards (1)Spoilers for Game of Thrones are in this post.

I watch Game of Thrones live every week with a few friends. Yesterday I did something for the first time ever: After a certain segment of the main battle, I picked up my remote and rewound for about 15 seconds to watch it again. It was quite possibly the best 15 seconds of any battlefield scene on television or film.

A day has passed, and it’s occurred to me in the meantime that the entire battle was one of the best I’ve ever seen. There are a number of epic movies with giant battlefield scenes, most notably the Lord of the Rings trilogy and Braveheart. But I think The Battle of the Bastards might be even better. Here’s why:

  1. It pits a truly great villain against a truly great hero. I don’t think I’m alone in despising Ramsay. But man, he’s fascinating to watch, largely because he’s so damn clever and cruel. His strategies are brilliant. And Jon Snow is as sympathetic a hero as you can get.
  2. I didn’t know who would win the battle. Maybe you knew, or at least had a strong hunch. I didn’t. George RR Martin has created a world where sometimes the bad guys win. The uncertainty this provides added to the tension and stakes of the battle.
  3. I felt like I was on the battlefield. Lots of these epic battles end up just looking like hordes of ants running over each other as you watch them from above. This battle puts you in the middle of the chaos, whether its horses charging around you or a wall of shields constricting upon you.
  4. It was not fun. Look, I love watching Gimli and Legolas flirt with each other on the battlefield. But real fantasy battles aren’t fun. They are fields of death and mud and horror. They are places where you get trampled and suffocate under bodies. Not that realism always equates to entertaining, but it works here.
  5. The cinematography is captivating. It’s stunning. Not just the overhead shots, but also the uncut in-the-moment shots that last way longer than you normally see in a battle. Instead of 1-second cuts, we get 5, 10, even 15 seconds of uninterrupted combat. That’s unheard of.
  6. There’s a giant. Just like The Rock, Giants make every battle better.

Best battlefield scene ever on television or film. That’s my opinion. I’d love to hear yours.

4 thoughts on “Was the Best Battlefield Scene Ever on Game of Thrones This Week?”

  1. Yes, yes it was. I was wowed throughout that whole thing for the same reasons you were. It pretty much blew away every similar combat I’d ever seen, between LotR, Braveheart, etc. Jon needed to win, so I didn’t agree with your second point. I knew that they wouldn’t kill Jon (again) in that fight. That said, I didn’t know how they would deus ex machina him out of that even though they totally foreshadowed it and I just forgot. I’ve been really impressed with this season, though I wonder how much of it is that it’s just quality, and how much of it is because for the first time ever, I don’t know what is happening next.

  2. As a side note, I don’t understand why Rickon existed. I’m sure GRRM maybe had a plan for him at first? But in 5 books, it never came to pass. Nor did it in the series. One could argue the only thing he’s ever done is die in front of Jon, in theory to light Jon up even more…except with either the books or the series, Jon and Rickon could not have really been close.


Leave a Reply

Discover more from jameystegmaier.com

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading