Wingfest 2010

Last weekend, Trevor had people over for Pizzafest 2010–basically, a bunch of people went out during halftime of the Rams game, picked up pizzas from different restaurants, and brought them back to Trev’s place to try.

It was a lot of fun, so I decided to host a similar function this week, but with buffalo wings. Most people bought wings from local restaurants, which I’ll rank below, but one guy made wings at home. They were fall-off-the-bone good.

My rankings:

  1. Culpepper’s: These were classic wings, crispy on the outside, moist on the inside, with just the right amount and flavor of sauce. I’ve had these before and wasn’t all that impressed, but today they were so good that I wanted to cover myself in chicken skin and dip myself in Culpepper sauce (yes, I’m aware that doesn’t make any sense).
  2. Ozzie’s: Almost identical to Culpepper’s, but they had slightly less sauce.
  3. Buffalo Wild Wings: I know, it’s a chain, but their wings are darn good. They’re just meat and flavor, nothing else getting in the way of the good stuff.
  4. Syberg’s: With their mustard-based sauce, these had the most unique flavor of the bunch.
  5. St. Louis Pizza and Wings: These wings were decent, but they were doused in a really watery sauce.
  6. Wing Stop: Very similar to St. Louis Pizza and Wings. As several of us commented, these tasted really unhealthy.
  7. Hooters: Honestly, these didn’t even seem like wings. They were fried chicken, heavily breaded and greasy. They weren’t bad, but they don’t fit into the category of wings.

After the event, some other friends suggested we try the wings at Weber’s, Mangia, and Pi Pizza.

What do you think? What are your favorite wings in St. Louis. Or if you don’t live in St. Louis, what do you think makes the perfect buffalo wing?